10 Best Eyelid Scrubs | Avenova vs Ocusoft vs Heyedrate vs Cliradex
July 21, 202012 min read
Burning, Oily, or Crusty Eyelids? What Is Blepharitis?
Blepharitis, meibomian gland dysfunction, and associated dry eye syndrome affect 30 million Americans. Due to this staggering amount of people that need help with eyelid disease, a flood of new products have come to the market in recent years.
Blepharitis is most likely due to an overgrowth of bacteria on your eyelids (naturally occuring bacteria), which create a discharge that looks like dandruff.
Symptoms of blepharitis include burning, oily, and crusty eyelids. You might also notice that in the morning your eyelids are stuck together.
How To Treat Blepharitis, and What is the Best Treatment for Blepharitis?
One simple way to treat blepharitis... CLEAN EYELIDS!
Clean eyelids help soothe symptoms of blepharitis, meibomian gland dysfunction (MGD), gunky, crusty eyelids, and dry, irritated eyes. Therefore the key to solving your eyelid problems is simply keeping your eyelids clean, which can be done with a prescription or an over-the-counter eyelid scrub.
Here, I put together the top five eyelid scrubs I use in my clinic, including the one I currently use for all my patients.
Released in June 2017, Heyedrate Lid & Lash Cleanser is one of the first over-the-counter hypochlorous acid sprays, with comparable ingredients to Avenova below (#2).
This natural, non-detergent based spray is perfect for deep cleaning the skin, which makes it great for soothing any skin irritation you have, such as cuts, scrapes, eyelid bumps, irritated eyes, redness, swelling, burning, itching, gunky, or crustiness of the eyelid margin.
This is my "go-to" product for patients in my clinic currently. It is very gentle and I have had great success with my patients.
MediViz Tea Tree Eyelid Cleaning Wipes are exfoliating, purified, hypoallergenic eyelid scrubs. According to their listing on Amazon, they:
TEA TREE OIL KILLS DEMODEX EYELASH MITES - Tea Tree Oil eliminates demodex mites from the skin and soothes irritation, crusty eyelashes, and clogged meibomian glands, leaving you with the clean eyelids and comfort you’re looking for.
DECREASES EYELID BACTERIAL GROWTH - By cleaning eyelids daily, you remove unwanted dead skin cells, microorganisms, and debris to leave your eyelid skin feeling brand new.
PROMOTES YOUTHFUL LOOKING EYELIDS - Your eyes need daily, gentle exfoliation just like your body, and tea tree eyelid wipes are a simple way to cleanse and exfoliate at the same time.
LIFTS AND FIRMS EYELIDS, REDUCES EYELID WRINKLES - Exfoliating promotes collagen production, which makes tissue stronger and promotes a youthful appearance, keeping you looking younger.
Open packet and remove MediViz Eyelid Wipe. Unfold wipe, close eye, and wipe eyelid and eyelashes with a gentle, sweeping motion. Do not flush wipe. Do not use wipe on open eye. No rinsing is necessary!
Where can I buy MediViz Tea Tree Eyelid Cleaning Wipes? What is the price?
Avenova Spray is the first prescription, FDA-approved, non-detergent based, non-antibiotic product shown to be successful in the treatment of such common eye conditions as blepharitis, meibomian gland dysfunction, and associated dry eye syndrome.
I used this in my clinic for two years and had great results. I now use the Heyedrate Lid & Lash Cleanser on this list for my patients because the price is more affordable and it is over-the-counter.
Avenova Spray's 2 Ingredients: Neutrox (pure hypochlorous acid, 0.01% as a preservative) in saline
This natural, non-detergent based foaming cleanser is made with gentle liquid soap, for a refreshingly rich lather, and 19 botanicals and plant extracts selected for their potent antioxidant properties. This includes tea tree oil, aloe vera, lavender, lemon, and peppermint essential oils.
Ingredients for Heyedrate Tea Tree Foaming Face Wash
Directions for Heyedrate Tea Tree Foaming Face Wash
To use, simply wet your face and pump 1-2 pumps into the palms of your hand. Work into a lather over your skin, and then rinse thoroughly. If you decide to use this over your eyelids, make sure to rinse well. This is a soap formula, so there is a potential for it to burn if it gets directly in your eyes. Pat dry, and you're finished!
Where can I buy Heyedrate Tea Tree Foaming Face Wash? What is the price?
MediViz Eyelid Cleaning Wipes can do quite a bit. According to their listing on Amazon, they:
DECREASE EYELID BACTERIAL GROWTH - By Cleaning your Eyelids and Lashes daily, you remove unwanted dead skin cells and debris. The removal of old makeup promotes healthy overall eye health.
PROMOTE YOUNGER SHINIER LOOKING EYELIDS - Your eyes need daily gentle exfoliating just like the rest of your body. By practicing daily eyelid exfoliation, you remove dead older looking cells on your eyelids. By removing oily dead skin cells, your eyelids will be looking more youthful. Excess dead cell buildup can lead to styes and other eye problems.
LIFT AND FIRM UPPER EYELIDS - Exfoliating also promotes collagen production which can make that thin, fragile tissue stronger and more resilient. After exfoliation all skin is more absorbent and receptive to the benefits of corrective skin products and your eyes are no exception.
REDUCE EYELID WRINKLES - Gentle daily exfoliation of the eye area can help it look younger and glowing by creating a smoother surface that better reflects light. A gentle eye exfoliator will keep the skin elastic enough to flatten out and look youthful again.
REMOVE UNWANTED MAKEUP - It is recommended by Optometrists and Ophthalmologists to to gently exfoliate the eyelids after removing your makeup—every night! Very lightly sweep a soft, moist washcloth over the surfaces of your eyelids and through the roots of your lashes. This will lightly remove loose surface cells and prevent buildup on your lash line.
Cliradex Wipes are a great preservative-free lid wipe that contains 4-Terpineol (T40), which is an active ingredient used to eliminate demodex mites (YES, mites in your eyelash follices). It can also help with redness, swelling, burning, itchiness, and crustiness of the eyelid margin.
I used this before Avenova came to the market, from 2010 until 2012. With the newer products on the market, like Avenova and Heyedrate Lid & Lash Cleanser, I no longer use Cliradex products regularly. This was mostly reserved for Demodex, or eyelash mites, but I now use a more natural product, Heyedrate Tea Tree Oil Soap.
Systane Lid Wipes help reduce redness, swelling, burning, itching, irritation, and crustiness on the eyelid margins.
I used this before Avenova came to the market, from 2010 until 2012. With the newer products on the market, like Avenova and Heyedrate Lid & Lash Cleanser, I no longer use Systane wipes with my patients.
Systane Lid Wipes' 7 Ingredients:
Purified Water USP, Peg-200 Hydrogenated Glyceryl Palmitate, Disodium Laureth Sulfosuccinate, Cocoamido Propyl Amine Oxide, Peg-80 Glyceryl Cocoate, Benzyle Alcohol And Ede tate Disodium
Directions for Systane Eyelid Wipes
Unfold pre-moistened pad and wrap over finger
Close eye and gently cleanse lid using side-to-side strokes
Do not touch eye directly
Repeat for other lid
Leave on for best results
No rinsing necessary
Where can I buy Systane Eyelid Wipes? What is the price of Systane Eyelid Wipes?
Ocusoft Lid Scrub Pre Moistened Pads are another detergent based eyelid scrub that has been used for many years to reduce redness, swelling, burning, itchiness, irritation, and crustiness from the eyelid margins. These are used for effectively removing oil, debris and desquamated skin from the eyelids.
I used this before Avenova came to the market, from 2010 until 2012. With the newer products on the market, like Avenova and Heyedrate Lid & Lash Cleanser, I no longer use Ocusoft products regularly.
Ocusoft Lid Scrub PLUS Pre Moistened Pads' 12 Ingredients:
We Love Eyes eyelid scrub is a tea tree based foaming eyelid cleanser that was recently released. It also helps reduce redness, swelling, burning, itchiness, irritation, and crustiness from the eyelid margins, but has tea tree oil in it, which helps with demodex eyelash mites as well. We Love Eyes eyelid scrub is effective at removing oil, debris and desquamated skin from the eyelids.
Hygiene in general is an important factor when it comes to keeping the overall bacteria load down (Staph which is the most common cause of blepharitis). We use a tea tree soap for our body and face in the shower and by the sink.
Limit the use of contact lenses when you have gunky eyelids and a very "active" blepharitis. This will increase bacteria in and around the eyelid, therefore worsening your bacteria.
FAQs About Avenova Hypochlorous Acid Eye Spray Solution
What is Avenova?
Avenova is a proprietary hypochlorous acid spray solution for the treatment of blepharitis and dry eyes. It’s patented formula makes it unique among many other hypochlorous acid cleansers on the market. It is now available both with a prescription from your eye doctor at your local pharmacy and without one on Amazon.
Is Avenova a prescription?
For years, Avenova was only available by prescription. Recently, in 2019, Avenova’s 20mL variation went over the counter for purchase on Amazon.com. Those with insurance benefits may wish to still purchase Avenova with a prescription, while others have turned to Amazon or other brands of hypochlorous acid.
Is Avenova FDA approved?
Yes, Avenova is FDA approved for the treatment of blepharitis. Avenova is one of the only pure hypochlorous acid cleansers on the market today. Avenova is the only hypochlorous acid product that is FDA cleared for safe, long-term use around the eyes while reducing bacterial load on the lids and lashes, helping to keep your lids & eyes healthy.
Does Avenova kill Demodex?
No studies have shown that Avenova kills demodex directly, but we do know that hypochlorous acid cleansers will kill bacteria and other organisms on contact. Since demodex feed on these organisms, hypochlorous acid can be a wonderful solution for those with demodex eyelash mites.
What is comparable to Avenova?
When comparing all of the hypochlorous acid cleansers on the market today, we recommend Heyedrate Lid and Lash Cleanser as a great alternative to Avenova. Heyedrate does not use sodium hypochlorite in their production process, and it is not generated in the final product. Heyedrate Lid and Lash Cleanser contains just three ingredients: Hypochlorous acid, electrolyzed water, and sodium chloride.
With a prescription but without insurance, 40mL Avenova will cost around $300 at your pharmacy. You can purchase the 20mL version on Amazon for around $30, although you are unable to use any insurance benefits to pay for this.
Does Avenova treat blepharitis?
Avenova, and other hypochlorous acid eyelid cleansers, are great treatments for blepharitis because they kill bacteria on contact. This can help balance the bacteria on the eyelids, leading to less inflammation and discomfort with the eyes and eyelids.
What do you think of this list? What have you tried? Let us know in the comments below!
AMAZON AFFILIATE INFORMATION -We, Eye Love, LLC, are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Leave a comment
Comments will be approved before showing up.
Also in Dry Eye - Dr. Zigler discusses signs, symptoms, treatment